Measuring accessibility of popular websites while using Tor

Abstract

Tor is an anonymity network used by a vast number of users in order to protect their privacy on the internet. It should not come as a surprise that this service is also used for abuse such as Denial of service attacks and other malicious activities because of the anonymity it provides. For protecting themselves from this abuse, websites block Tor in various ways. We investigate the extent and frequency of this kind of blocking by requesting the Alexa top 1000 websites with and without Tor with the objective of highlighting the differential treatment observed by privacy-minded users. We build upon existing studies by using diverse metrics to measure discrimination and by extending our search to three sub pages of websites for detecting sophisticated blocking. We find at least 25.8% of the Alexa top 1000 websites discriminating on the home page against Tor users as opposed to 20.03% observed in previous studies. This number rises to 31.7% after including the three sub pages. We also discover new types of blocks such as Tor users being served old or different versions of websites. We categorize the blocked websites and find that Online Shopping and Finance/ Banking categories discriminate most against Tor while Social Networking sites and Search Engines discriminate the least.