Assessment of numerical methods for estimating the wall shear stress in turbulent Herschel–Bulkley slurries in circular pipes

Abstract

This article concerns the turbulent flow of Herschel–Bulkley slurries through circular horizontal pipes; in particular, that of concentrated domestic slurry obtained upon separation of domestic waste water and reduction in the use of water for domestic purposes. Experiments with a rheologically equivalent clay (kaolin) slurry indicated a non-Newtonian behaviour of the Herschel–Bulkley type. A modified wall function was developed to enable the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes simulation of Herschel–Bulkley slurries to estimate the wall shear stress. Despite the accuracy achieved, the use of Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes models for an entire waste water system is impractical. Therefore, this article assesses the accuracy of semi-empirical models in estimating frictional losses. It also discusses possible modifications of existing models to encompass Herschel–Bulkley behaviour. An evaluation suggests that most existing models deliver estimates of comparable accuracy; however, the probability of these estimates being reliable, while accounting for experimental errors in quantifying the actual frictional losses, is rather low.